Table of Contents
TLDR
Alan Milburn’s review of youth participation calls for education and training systems to adapt to young people’s lives, rather than the other way round. With nearly one million young people not in education, employment or training (NEET), year-round enrolment, flexible GCSE and A level assessment, accessible exam centres and portable access arrangements are essential if young people are to have a genuine second chance at education – whenever they are ready. NEC calls for supported distance learning to be recognised as a core route back into education, and flexible supported provision to be designed in from the start.
Alan Milburn’s review of youth participation, From a Welfare State to a Working State, was published on 17th November. It runs to nearly 300 pages, and it needs to. Nearly one million young people are not in education, employment or training (NEET), and there is no single lever that fixes that.
Most of the coverage will focus on welfare and employers. I read it as the leader of an organisation founded in 1963 to reach people the education system had missed, and one passage made me pause. On college funding, Milburn argues that:
No young person should be told to wait until next September, and that systems should adapt to the lives of young people, not the other way round.
That is what NEC has done for six decades. For many of our learners the timetable, the building, or the September start was the barrier, not their ability or ambition. That is why we enrol year-round, so students can start when they are ready instead of losing months waiting for a new term.
The report is candid about the gap. It finds that the offer for 19 to 24 year-olds who need a second chance is fragmented, with too few short, modular or in-year routes back, and that further education numbers for that age group have fallen by around 13% since 2017/18. It also notes that only around one in five young people who miss Level 2 English and maths at 16 have both by 19, and that entering people again and again before they are ready is not the same as rigour.
Who Are the Young People Not in Education, Employment or Training
The report is clear that this is not one group.
Nearly a third of NEET young people have GCSEs as their highest qualification, and one in seven has a degree. Health is now central: almost half of NEET respondents in the review’s survey reported a long-term condition, with mental health and neurodevelopmental needs rising fastest. One young person told the review they missed their expected GCSE grades while their health condition was uncontrolled. They went on to a first-class science degree and were still screened out by employers because of those early results.
That matches the learners we meet. Many are academically capable. What has stopped them is circumstance, not ability: anxiety, ill health, caring responsibilities, care experience, a school that couldn’t hold on to them.
Flexibility Has to Reach the Exam Hall
Flexible study only helps if the exam at the end of it is flexible too, and for GCSEs and A levels it mostly isn’t.
These qualifications are largely sat in a fixed summer series, so a learner who is ready in April may wait a year. A learner outside school needs a centre willing to take them as a private candidate. Any access arrangements, such as extra time or a separate room, have to be applied for by that centre, backed by evidence of how they normally work, to deadlines set months ahead.
For a young person with no school history, no SENCo and a health condition that is the reason they are studying at home, that can be where the door closes. The report’s “assessment when ready” and modular assessment are welcome, but it frames them as a ten-year direction.
What the Milburn Report Misses
Supported distance learning, and how its learners are assessed, does not appear anywhere in the report. Yet the architecture it proposes (a Youth Opportunity Service in every place, UCAS-style local access points, a digital Open College where people accumulate qualifications at their own pace) will decide which routes a young person and their adviser ever see. The Open College only works if there is somewhere to sit the exams. If flexible, supported provision isn’t designed in from the start, it will be left out.
So we would ask for four things:
- Local access points should list flexible and distance routes alongside colleges, and skills funding, including what devolves to strategic authorities, should treat flexible provision as core.
- Exam access should be treated as infrastructure: approved venues in every region, with sittings through the year.
- Access arrangements should be portable between centres and awarding bodies, with a funded route to assessment for learners outside school.
- The tilt towards technical routes should not close the door on GCSE foundations. The report’s own pre-apprenticeships depend on English and maths, and “assessment when ready” is where flexible study helps most.
“A first chance matters, and so does a second or a third, at a time and in a place that works for the learner.”
Esther Chesterman, CEO, National Extension College